About Pilgrim Congregational Church

The Founding of Pilgrim Church

In the spring of 1992, the National Association of Congregational Christian Churches (NACCC), headquartered in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, came to The Reverend Kent Estler, our Founding Minister, and asked him if he’d be interested in starting a new Congregational Church in the Northern New Jersey area. Pilgrim Church was incorporated with the state of New Jersey on November 13, 1992.

In January, 1993, Pilgrim Church called the Reverend Dr. Kenyon J. Wildrick as its Senior Minister and The Reverend Virginia L. Scott, was called as the church’s associate minister in March of that year.

While worshipping in the public school system in Milburn/Short Hills, NJ for four and a half years, Pilgrim Church’s congregation and ministers worked arduously to find a location for a permanent sanctuary and in January, 1996, they purchased 5 and 1/3 acres of land at 105 Mountainview Road in Warren, NJ. Jon Rocker was hired as Pilgrim Church’s builder and ground was broken for a house of worship in November, 1996.

Pilgrim Church opened its doors for its first service of worship in October, 1997, and over the years so many wonderful people have stepped forward to join our founding members in this new venture of faith. We invite you to check our calendar of events for a list of this year’s special events!

Pilgrim Congregational Church Steeple

The Building Of Our Church 1996

PCC Church Plans

Ken receiving a financial gift from a Imori Megumi Church in Tokyo

Interior During Construction

Interior During Construction

Exterior During Construction

Our builder Jon Rocker, when we broke ground for our new sanctuary on November 14, 1996

Exterior During Construction

Rev. Ken Wildrick standing in the foundation

Exterior During Construction

Exterior During Construction

Ken standing by parts of the steeple, shaking hands with Paul Stillwaggon, Realtor who helped us secure the property

Future Home of the Pilgrim Congregational Church

Future Home of the Pilgrim Congregational Church

Exterior at Christmas Time

Our Congregational Heritage

Exterior of Church

The Congregational denomination came to America on the Mayflower. It stems from the founding in 1620 of Plymouth Colony by the Pilgrims and the Massachusetts Bay Colony by the Puritans. These early settlers left the Old World and came to the new in order that they might be free individuals to worship God according to their own consciences. That individual freedom remains the most proud tenant of congregationalism today. In Pilgrim Church it means that we never stop seeking answers to even the most complex questions, as each individual member attempts to follow the age old commandment of Jesus that we all worship God not only with our hearts and souls but also with our minds.

Recognizing the need to stimulate the minds of their children, the Pilgrims established schools which were the forerunners of the American system of free educatåion. Aware of the value of trained leaders and a rational approach to faith, the Congregational churches also began a program of organizing and sustaining colleges that has continued for well over 350 years. Harvard, founded in 1636, was the first of a long list that now stretches the length and breadth of the country. Yale, Amherst, Bowdoin, Carlton, Grinell, Dartmouth, Mount Holyoke, Oberlin, Pacific, Pomona, Smith and Wellesley—these and 32 other institutions of higher learning owe their origin to the Congregational devotion to developing the God-given gift of intelligence. That God-given gift is still cultivated in every worship service of a true Congregational church today.

Pilgrim Congregational Church is proud of its magnificent heritage and it is its constant prayer that the faith of all might be further developed through the preaching and teaching that it brings to its home in Warren.

Pilgrim Church is pleased to be an active, contributing member of the Connecticut Fellowship of Congregational Christian Churches and a member of the National Association of the Congregational Christian Churches with headquarters in Oak Creek, Wisconsin.

Our Founders

Reverend Dr Kenyon J Wildrick

Reverend Dr. Kenyon J. Wildrick

The Reverend Dr. Kenyon J. Wildrick, our Minister Emeritus, served as Senior Minister of Pilgrim Church for 13 years. He had a Master of Divinity degree (1958) and a Master of Theology degree (1963) from Princeton Theological Seminary and an honorary doctorate from his alma mater, TrinityCollege, in Hartford, Connecticut. Dr. Wildrick served as a Trustee for the Center of Theological Inquiry in Princeton, NJ, charged with charting the theology of the world for the next 100 years, and as a Trustee for the Presbyterian Homes of New Jersey. Upon his retirement in 2006, the congregation unanimously voted him to be our Minister Emeritus. He served his church as a cherished Trustee until his passing in 2024.

Reverend Virginia L. Scott

Reverend Virginia L. Scott 

The Reverend Virginia L. Scott was called by our congregation to be our new senior minister in June, 2006. Ginnie has a Master of Divinity degree (1979) and a Master of Theology degree (1984) from Princeton Theological Seminary, with a concentration in New Testament Studies. She has served on the Overlook Hospital Chaplaincy Board and been president of the Millburn Short Hills Clergy Association and secretary of the Executive Committee of the Connecticut Fellowship of Congregational Christian Churches. Ginnie retired at the end of 2024 and will return from time to time as a guest minister. An outstanding preacher, the congregation was always thrilled as well when she offered a children’s sermon to our children and those who are young in spirit on Sunday morning.

Reverend Kent Estler

Reverend Kent Estler

The Reverend Kent Estler, who sadly passed away in 2019, was our Founding Minister. He had a Master of Divinity from Drew Theological Seminary (1969).

Reverend Estlerwas instrumental in the formation of Pilgrim Congregational Church, helping us to obtain standing in the National Association of Christian Congregational Churches and gathering new members for our congregation.